More Overhead Reviews—and a Question

Yeah, I know, lay off the Shine already.

But let’s start with the reviews:

From SF Revu, Liviu Suciu:

For me this was the best story of the anthology and not surprising it is the one that involves exploration of Outer Space, namely a colony on the dark side of the moon – so it stays out of touch with humanity except for regular deliveries of technology and people that want to join – where humanity can “reboot” if needed and where the rules are designed to create a better society. In a past thread that mixes with the current one and explains how the colony came to be, we follow executive Roy Parekh setting up an insurance company with a twist. Sense of wonder, memorable characters and a superb ending made “Overhead” a story that induced me to follow Mr. Stoddard’s career from now on. I would love a novel that would expand this story since I think the necessary depth is there.

From Speculative Book Review,

While I greatly enjoyed almost all of Shine’s stories, a handful of those really impressed me. Jason Stoddard’s Overhead was one of them. It was a brilliant story written with a beautiful style. In Overhead, Stoddard uses flashbacks very intelligently to build his story on two alternate threads. The present thread develops the story while the flashback thread gives the reader more background helping her to understand the present thread. Furthermore, Stoddard manages to keep the suspense until the last page.

From Suite 101, Colin Harvey:

‘Overhead’ by Jason Stoddard shuttles setting between Earth and the Moon, and an embryonic lunar colony. Stoddard raises the stakes, bringing an intensity absent from much of the other fiction, making the payback all the greater. Highly Recommended.

From Financial Times (!):

But there are some strong stories: “Overhead”, Jason Stoddard’s sketch of a moon colony, is the best; Holly Phillips’s “Summer Ice”, set in a greener future metropolis, and Kay Kenyon’s “Castoff World”, also satisfy.

Author comment: is it surprising that financially oriented peeps would think a story about an insurance salesman is the best?

From SF Crowsnest, Stephen Hunt:

Jason Stoddard’s ‘Overhead’ is only partly set on Earth, the other part of the action is on an idealistic, experimental lunar colony. The colony develops from a dubious insurance company in the kind of unexpected development that typifies many of this anthology’s stories. Technology and social developments that are often assumed in SF to have a negative future have been turned on their head to great effect.

From SF Signal and The Huffington Post (!!):

Two warily pet the woolly mammoth in the room: space exploration. Of these, Marie Ness’ “Twittering the Stars” (despite its gimmicky structure and grating title) is absorbing and complex, whereas Jason Stoddard’s too-earnest “Overhead” lets its most exciting premise – Europan life – lie totally fallow. In compensation, the latter contains the sole character in the anthology who’s instantly memorable: a heroic-despite-himself version of Henry the Navigator.

There are a lot of other reviews that don’t mention Overhead specifically, which I’ll take to mean one of the following:

a. The reviewer hated it and was being polite.
b. It made no impression on them at all.

Which is fine . . . ya can’t please everyone.

Now, the question from Jetse de Vries, based on Gardner Dozois and Rich Horton’s lukewarm-to-cautiously-positive reaction to Shine in the April issue of Locus magazine (not online.)

I suppose we can agree to disagree about the ‘greatness’ of certain stories, but I do wonder why an anthology full of stories where people try to change things for the better needs to be ‘approved’, while anthologies where the population is decimated, the Earth is brought to the brink of destruction (sometimes beyond) and nihilistic characters gleefully engage in violence get that stamp of approval by default. Maybe this says something about the current mindset of written SF?

My opinion: for every negative thing happening in the world today, there are one or more equally positive things. Spend some time on PhysOrg. Look at the crazy people at Copenhagen Suborbitals or the Open Space Movement. Check out the amazing beauty of Festo’s robotics. We’re on the edge of some truly amazing breakthroughs — and, no, they aren’t all going to be used to propagate the agenda of large, evil organizations.

So, to the naysayers, fear-mongers, and doom-merchants: Stand aside, and watch us make a future worth living in!

May 16th, 2010 / 1,316 Comments »

1,316 Responses to “More Overhead Reviews—and a Question”

  1. huggies coupons Says:

    whoah this blog is great i really like studying your posts. Stay up the great paintings! You recognize, lots of people are hunting around for this info, you could aid them greatly.

  2. huggies coupons Says:

    My brother recommended I would possibly like this website. He used to be entirely right. This post actually made my day. You can not imagine just how so much time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

  3. cable tray Says:

    well, Shea Butter have some special medicinal properties too aside from cosmetic applications~

  4. typical symptoms of pregnancy Says:

    I was trying to find this. Really refreshing take on the information. Thanks a lot.

  5. Victoria Secret Pink Says:

    Just want to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your post is simply cool and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

  6. berat badan Says:

    Whats up, I just hopped over to your site via StumbleUpon. Now not one thing I’d generally read, but I favored your feelings none the less. Thank you for making something worth reading.

  7. Blue light acne treatment Says:

    peanut butters are very tasty, the only problem is that i have some very bad peanut allergy~

  8. provillus Says:

    All I can do would be to bump the thread up, and I really learned a whole lot from our Moderator, and I also have some other viewpoints, maybe we can share it if we have opportunity.

  9. provillus Says:

    Hello there, just became alert to your blog by way of Google, and found that it is truly informative. I?m going to watch out for brussels. I?ll be grateful if you continue this in future. Many individuals will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  10. Agio Home Says:

    I was recommended this web site by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my problem. You’re incredible! Thanks!

  11. liposuction treatment Says:

    liposuction surgery is one of the famous cosmetic treatment for beauty care. Lipo can be used to treat aging, weight loss problems

  12. New York car donation Says:

    Thanks so much pertaining to giving us an update on this matter on your web page. Please realize that if a fresh post becomes available or if perhaps any changes occur on the current article, I would want to consider reading a lot more and finding out how to make good using of those techniques you discuss. Thanks for your efforts and consideration of other folks by making this site available.

  13. womens underwear Says:

    soem sites that offer download games have viruses and spywares on it. so make sure to have some antivirus on your PC`

  14. rabbit vibrator Says:

    Merci for the wonderful posting! I really enjoyed reading it, you can be a great author.I will remember to bookmark your site and may come back in the foreseeable future. I want to support you to definitely continue your remarkable posts, have a nice evening!

  15. Chana Vache Says:

    Hello there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share. Kudos!

  16. Carl Cedillos Says:

    Greater product or service and also exelent benefits to the individuals who are seeking the particular lower price direct mobile phone collection here’s the item CALL AT THIS POINT 866-943-6381